Simply The Best Pizza . . . And So Much More!

The Patriot-News
by MIMI BRODEUR
ADDED SPICE

Menu, dining room grow at The Pizza Grille


RATING - 4 FORKS

3817 Gettysburg Road Lower Allen Twp.
920-5350
Hours: 11 a.m.-10 p.m. Monday-Thursday; 11 a.m.-11 p.m. Friday-Saturday
Pizza, main course entrees, sandwiches, soups, salads, pastas First come, first served Entrees: $12-$22
Full bar, selected value for your money wine list.
Parking in lot
Major credit cards
No smoking


The name, Pizza Grille, is deceiving. Pizza is only a small slice of the pie being passed around at the Pizza Grille location that opened recently at the former Harding's Restaurant in Lower Allen Twp. Although the restaurant draws its crowd for its signature gourmet pizzas, fare such as soups, salads, entrees, pastas, desserts and bar listings fills the menu pages, too.

This second Pizza Grille is far from a clone of the ongoing original establishment in Lemoyne. For starters, this place is huge and seats more than 200 in a divided dining room, at the adjacent barroom and on the patio.

High ceilings with exposed vents add spaciousness and an upbeat din. Paned windows create an airy feel to streamlined furnishings and banquettes that are accented by mirrors and limited views of the kitchen.

It has been open only a month, but the place is hopping. The room was full and some folks were waiting for a table to open up on a recent Saturday visit. The restaurant doesn't take reservations, but the food and quick, knowledgeable service keep lag time to a minimum.

The restaurant features an all-season patio. Garage doors surrounding the patio open when weather permits. "We're going to add an imported cheese plate to the menu at some point," says Doug Barry, who owns both Pizza Grilles with wife Deb. "It'll be really nice in the summer to sit out there with a bottle of wine and cheeses. "

For starters, nothing gets the appetite going like the grilled eggplant roll ($5.95). This dish is also available as an entree for $11.25. I loved this starter. It's so refreshing and clean tasting. The flavors are separate, yet the textures merge. Twin bundles of aubergine hide an interior of pine nuts, Romano and mozzarella cheeses and an ever-so-slightly sweet taste of garlic. Pesto adds a shimmering Kelly green stripe over the loosely wrapped eggplant packages, which soak in a luscious bath of tomato sauce. The only thing missing from this perfect picture was bread to sop up excess sauce. Texture, taste and color make this starter a must-order.

"The menu, which began with 11 pizzas and several sandwiches and salads, has really developed itself. Everything is like a signature item. We like creating something fun and a little out of the ordinary like the eggplant starter," Doug Barry says.

Colorful pizzas, with an array of toppings, kept spinning out of the busy, organized kitchen. The signature pies are creative, from cheese steak pizza ($5.75) to seafood pizza ($9.95), which is topped with mozzarella cheese and polka-dotted with shrimp, clams, scallops and crab.

A large, thick bed of chopped Romaine leaves is the basis for the salmon Caesar salad ($11.75). Simply prepared salmon filet is expertly poached but needs additional salt and pepper to enhance natural juices.

"We only serve vinaigrette dressings. There are no creamy dressings or even cream soups. And there are no fryers in the kitchen. We're trying to get people to eat healthier," Barry says.

Caesar dressing is eggless but still has pungency from anchovies, garlic and Parmesan cheese. Triangular Parmesan pizza toasts sit around the salad.

Don't think you're getting off lightly by ordering the grilled vegetable sandwich ($6.25). This sandwich looks like it has as many layers as the bed in the fairy tale "The Princess and the Pea." Grill-marked summer squash, zucchini, tomatoes and tender lettuce leaves make a mountain out of these molehill ingredients. Roasted garlic focaccia bread adds even more springiness with its extra two-inches of height. Sandwiches come with a small salad.

I was full by dessert but could not resist tasting the peanut butter pie. This pie, with its telltale chocolate cookie crust, is reminiscent of the peanut butter pie from Sophia's on Market because Sophia's makes it. There is no willpower strong enough to combat silky-smooth and buttery pie. Another hit is the velvety chocolate creme brulee made by Cheesecakes, Etc. in Carlisle. Both desserts are worth all their calories.

This second Pizza Grille just proves the point that it is a super idea to build on a good thing.

Restaurant critic Mimi Brodeur has an extensive background in the food business. Her reviews appear weekly.




Copyright 2005, 2006 The Patriot-News Co. All Rights Reserved. Used with permission.


The Pizza Grille ® is a registered trademark. © 2011 The Pizza Grille. All rights reserved.

HOME

OUR MENU

DRINK SELECTIONS

RAVE REVIEWS

DINERS' CHOICE AWARD

PATRIOT - CAMP HILL

PATRIOT - LEMOYNE

THE SENTINEL

MODE WEEKLY

LOCATIONS & HOURS